Do 100-year-old Sourdough Starters Exist?

By Tom Cucuzza, © The Sourdough Journey, November 2026

In 2026, I compared the DNA profiles of two sourdough starters from the same source. After 14 months in different locations, with different flours and feeding routines, the same species of yeast and bacteria still dominated both starters. What surprised me was just how similar they were.

An often-repeated claim is that if you bring someone else’s starter into your kitchen, new microbes will quickly take over. If two starters could stay this similar after 14 months apart, could some of the microbes in a starter carry on for a century?

Before my starter DNA experiment, I was skeptical, too. I’m not anymore.

You can find the full results of this study in my research paper, “Inside the Invisible World of Sourdough Starters.”  

The Claims

We have all seen the claims of “heritage” or “heirloom” starters:

  • “100-year-old starter from France”
  • “Genuine California Gold Rush starter”
  • “A family starter handed down through generations”

These types of claims are often dismissed as marketing gimmicks or fanciful stories that cannot be proven, because many people presume that if new microbes are introduced through daily feedings, what could possibly remain of a starter from a century ago?

The Research

As I was researching the microbiology of sourdough starters, I learned two important findings:

  • Some sourdough starters have credible claims of more than a century of continuous maintenance, and
  • Mature sourdough starters can retain remarkably stable microbial profiles over long periods of time.

That does not mean I believe every story attached to a jar of starter, but now when evaluating a claim of a heritage starter we can ask two questions:

  • Does the starter have a credible maintenance history?
  • Does the microbiology make that kind of persistence plausible?

Is the History Credible?

A DNA test alone cannot tell us how old a sourdough starter is. It can tell us which microbes are in the starter today. A starter doesn’t come with a microbial birth certificate. To find out how old it is, we have to trace its history.

So, the first test of these claims is to understand if there is a credible chain of people who kept the starter going.  This is known as determining the “provenance.”

Provenance is the history of where something came from and how it reached its current owner.  This technique is often used to verify the background of works of art or antiquities.

For a heritage starter, that might mean examining records from a continuously operating bakery over hundreds of years, or a family account supported by letters, recipes, photographs, bakery records, or people who remember maintaining, using, or receiving a starter. Some histories will be stronger than others. “My grandmother gave it to me, and her mother gave it to her” is a starting point for an investigation, but is not the same as a century of documented records.

Also consider that a century is not an especially long span for oral history, so oral history should not be dismissed. My great-grandparents, whom I knew in my lifetime, were born in the late 1800s. Their firsthand accounts, passed directly to me, now bridge more than 100 years with just one telling. A starter’s history could span a century through a similarly short chain of people.  When claims begin spanning two hundred or more years, the written documentary record is more convincing evidence.

When considering the provenance of sourdough starters, we are looking to understand the record of continuous maintenance.  Continuous propagation of a live starter is the “gold standard” of starter maintenance and provenance. 

Here are examples of two European bakeries that publicly describe the age and care of their starters.

  • Grondona, Genoa, Italy: The family bakery describes its Madre Bianca sourdough starter as 150 years old and says it refreshes it every six to eight hours, 365 days a year. The family’s history reaches back to around 1850, when Francesco Grondona carried on his father’s practice of feeding and preserving the “white mother.” A later generation left a written record, too. Orlando Grondona kept a notebook with notes on how he cared for Madre Bianca.
  • Bäckerei Hahn, Bavaria, Germany: Rudolf Hahn, a fourth-generation member of the baking family, says the bakery made its starter when it opened in 1912, and it has been refreshed every day since. Five generations into the family business, the bakery says it still uses that starter in nearly all its breads.

Many other European bakeries, some notable American bakeries, and some family histories around the world describe similar, credible reports of continuous daily maintenance of a live starter over multiple generations, and spanning over 100 years. 

Rather than dismissing a claim outright, we should assess the validity of the claim.  

Suppose someone gives you a starter and says it came from a French bakery that opened in 1865.

  • Did they acquire it directly from the bakery? How was it maintained under their ownership?
  • Is there a documented history of the bakery? How far back can the bakery trace the starter and its continuous maintenance?

We can use these questions to determine the confidence level of a claim. 

The same starter story, told four ways

Confidence in the age claim

“I got it directly from the baker. The baker showed me records dating the starter to 1865 and explained how each generation kept it going and passed it on.”

High: Direct handoff, starter records, and a history of continuous maintenance

“I got it directly from the baker. The baker told me the starter had been used since 1865 and could trace who passed it down. Some details about how earlier generations kept it are missing.”

Substantial: Direct handoff and a credible chain of keepers, with some gaps in the maintenance history

“I got it from someone who said they received it from an identifiable French bakery. I know who gave it to me, and 1865 is when the bakery opened. I can’t confirm the earlier handoff or how long the starter was kept there.”

Limited: Known recent handoff, reported earlier handoff, and unverified maintenance history

“I got it from someone who said it came from a French bakery that opened in 1865. They couldn’t tell me which bakery, who received it from the baker, or how it was kept before it came to me.”

Low: Known recent handoff, with earlier handoffs and maintenance history untraceable

An incomplete historical record does not automatically make a claim false. We routinely assess historical claims by weighing the available evidence.

I think of this as establishing plausible provenance with different levels of confidence.

The Microbiology

The question of microbiology challenges deeply entrenched conventional wisdom.  As discussed, many bakers presume that if you bring another starter into your kitchen and maintain it with your flour, your water, and exposure to your environment, that it will inevitably turn into ‘your starter’ with some suggesting as quickly as after a single feeding.

The scientific research simply does not support this position.  First, consider the mechanics of cell reproduction in a sourdough starter.

“100 years old” does not mean that the same individual microbial cells have survived for 100 years.  Individual yeast and bacterial cells do age and die, but yeast reproduces primarily by budding, and bacteria by cell division.  These processes can create daughter cells that are exact genetic copies of the cells that came before them. Over time, the original cells disappear, but their microbial lineages continue through repeated reproduction and importantly – replication. 

Why don’t new microbes simply take over?

Sourdough starters are not simply a collection of all the microbes that cross their path.  A mature starter is an established, stable microbial ecosystem.

A mature sourdough starter typically has only one or two dominant yeast species and one to three dominant bacterial species. For a new species to take over, it has to outcompete the microbes that already dominate the starter. That’s survival of the fittest. The microbes best adapted to the conditions in that jar have the advantage. Just being “new” doesn’t give a newcomer an edge. The microbes already in the starter are producing new cells, too.

Each feeding gives the microbes a chance to compete, but the dominant microbes in a sourdough starter have won countless rounds of competition – they are the Olympic champions of that starter. 

But aren’t new competitors introduced with every feeding?

Yes, but new competitors are facing elite athletes perpetually at their prime, because unlike human athletes, the microbial Olympians do not lose their abilities or retire. Yeast and bacteria reproduce by making new cells that are, in practical terms, copies of themselves.  It is less like Olympic swimming champion Michael Phelps teaching his son to swim and more like Michael Phelps cloning himself before each race, forever.

What the Studies Found

As discussed, a 100-year-old starter is not a jar containing 100-year-old cells. It is a continuously maintained biological lineage whose descendants can persist from one generation to the next.  Note: Mutations and occasional sexual recombination or hybridization can introduce genetic changes into the population over time. Sourdough starters are not static and can change over time, but they have also shown more persistence than many may believe.  

The following three studies demonstrate the stability of sourdough starters over long periods of time.

Pham, Gänzle, and colleagues: Persistence at the strain level

In a 2024 study, Pham, Gänzle, and colleagues examined bacteria from the same four sourdough starters sampled years apart. They found evidence of bacterial strain-level persistence in three of the four starters, over intervals of up to 18 years.

“Strain-level” is even more specific than finding the same species. The researchers compared genomes and found closely related genetic markers consistent with persistence of the same strains.

Looking beyond the period they studied, the researchers concluded that “persistence over hundreds or thousands of years is possible, if not likely.”

The Auerbach comparison: Two branches, approximately 20 years apart

In the late 1990s, sourdough baker David Auerbach gave another baker a portion of his starter and they each maintained a branch separately in their own homes.   

Approximately 20 years later, both independently maintained branches were submitted to the Global Sourdough Project for DNA analysis and study. Their microbial profiles were remarkably similar.

The same yeast species and the same bacterial species dominated both starters. The proportions of two major yeast sequence types were strikingly close, and matching “rare” species were found in both starters.

My study: Two starters from the same source with 14 months of separate maintenance

After 14 months apart, the same yeast and bacterial species still dominated both starters. No new species had taken over either one. What surprised me even more was that both starters still shared several of the “stragglers,” species that each accounted for less than 1% of the DNA reads.

The two starters were tested at the species level, not the strain level, and the starters were not identical. The relative population mix of the two shared yeast species diverged. The same bacterial species accounted for nearly all the bacterial DNA reads in both samples.

While this study is of shorter duration, it challenges the widely held assumption that “local microbes will take over a starter when it is moved to a new location.”

Taken together, these three cases challenge the assumption that repeated feeding or relocation replaces a mature starter’s microbial identity.  Other studies show starters changing over time, but the three examples above demonstrate that microbial change is not inevitable.

The Final Test: The Expert Witness     

The microbiology is theoretically compelling, but people often ask me if I can “prove” that a starter contains any of the microbial lineages it contained 100 years ago.  I cannot, but importantly, I also cannot prove that it does not contain these microbes. 

Let’s imagine a hypothetical courtroom where a baker is accused of fraud for selling a “100-year-old sourdough starter.”

The accusation rests on the claim that a “100-year-old” starter cannot meaningfully exist.  After so many feedings, the original microbes must have disappeared.

The accused seller’s attorney presents a credible historical record of the starter. Generations of bakers maintained the culture and passed portions to their successors. The provenance is compelling.

Then the seller’s attorney calls a sourdough microbiologist to take the stand.

Attorney: “Does a 100-year-old starter need to contain individual cells that have been alive for 100 years?”

Expert Witness: “No. Microbial lineages continue through reproduction and genetic replication.”

Attorney: “Based on your knowledge of microbiology, can you establish that a continuously maintained starter contains no genetic copies of microbes that were present in it 100 years ago?”

Expert Witness: “No. Continuous reproduction can preserve a genetic lineage. Repeated feeding does not necessarily eliminate it.”

Attorney: “I rest my case.”

If I were sitting on the jury, I would believe the expert witness.

The Bottom Line

Do we have definitive proof of 100-year-old starters? No.  Do we have a strong counterargument to the conventional wisdom that they cannot exist? Yes.

We now understand:

  • There are credible claims of starters with 100+ years of continuous maintenance.
  • DNA studies show that some microbes can persist in a sourdough starter for a long time.
  • Microbes copy their DNA when they reproduce. That’s how a lineage from a century ago could still be alive in a starter today.
  • New “microbial arrivals” in a starter must compete against “Olympic champions, perpetually in their prime” to displace a dominant species.

If a starter has a credible history of being kept alive and passed down for a hundred years, can anyone prove that none of its microbial lineages goes back that far?

I certainly cannot. 

Arguing that a starter is simply a “random collection of the microbes that cross its path” now sounds more fanciful than a claim that a “100-year-old starter” exists.   

Support the Sourdough Journey

My research is independently funded.  If you would like to see more DNA research of sourdough starters, please consider supporting my research at thesourdoughjourney.com/donate.

More Reading

My research paper, “Inside the Invisible World of Sourdough Starters” covers my 14-month study in detail.  

Vanessa Kimbell’s article  “The myth of hundred year old sourdough.”                                                                                                                                                                            

Mike Avery, “Another Delicate Matter”, Sourdough Home (2019). A comparison of two branches of David Auerbach’s starter after about 20 years of separate maintenance.

Vi D. Pham and colleagues, “Does strain-level persistence of lactobacilli in long-term back-slopped sourdoughs inform on domestication of food-fermenting lactic acid bacteria?”

King Arthur Baking, “Debunking the biggest sourdough myths.”